1929 -- Glenn Stafford, Cornell, 175 pounds
1938 -- Jack Harkness, Harvard, 175 pounds
1941 -- Dick DiBatista, Penn, 175 pounds
1942 -- Dick DiBatista, Penn, 175 pounds
1951 -- Bradley Glass, Princeton, heavyweight
1953 -- Frank Bettucci, Cornell, 147 pounds
1953 -- Don Dickason, Cornell, 167 pounds
1959 -- Andy Fitch, Yale, 115 pounds
1959 -- Dave Auble, Cornell, 123 pounds
1960 -- Dave Auble, Cornell, 123 pounds
1975 -- Jim Bennet, Yale, 142 pounds
1994 -- David Hirsch, Cornell, 126 pounds
2000 -- Brett Matter, Penn, 157 pounds
2003 -- Travis Lee, Cornell, 125 pounds
2004 -- Jesse Jantzen, Harvard, 149 pounds
2005 -- Travis Lee, Cornell, 133 pounds
2006 -- Matt Valenti, Penn, 133 pounds
2007 -- Matt Valenti, Penn, 133 pounds

1941 -- Larry Pickett, Yale, Heavyweight
1951 -- George Graveson, Yale, 167 pounds
1958 -- Dick Vincent, Cornell, 147 pounds
1972 -- Emil Deliere, Princeton, 190 pounds
1978 -- John Sefter, Princeton, Heavyweight
1984 -- John Orr, Princeton, 142 pounds
1985 -- John Orr, Princeton, 142 pounds
1997 -- Brandon Slay, Penn, 167 pounds
1998 -- Brandon Slay, Penn, 167 pounds
2002 -- Greg Parker, Princeton, 174 pounds
2004 -- Tyler Baier, Cornell, 184 pounds
2006 -- Troy Nickerson, Cornell, 125 pounds

1930 -- W. Solano, Harvard, 165 pounds
1933 -- Pat Johnson, Harvard, 135 pounds
1952 -- Bradley Glass, Princeton, 191 pounds
2002 -- Jesse Jantzen, Harvard, 149 pounds
2002 -- Yoshi Nakamura, Penn, 157 pounds
2003 -- Jesse Jantzen, Harvard, 149 pounds
2006 -- Dustin Manotti, Cornell, 157 pounds
2007 -- Troy Nickerson, Cornell, 125 pounds