1888
Men’s Tennis -- V.G. Hall, doubles
Men’s Tennis -- Oliver Campbell, doubles

1889
Men’s Tennis -- Oliver Campbell, doubles
Men’s Tennis -- A.E. Wright, doubles

1904
Men’s Tennis -- Robert LeRoy, singles

1906
Men’s Tennis -- Robert LeRoy, singles

1919
Men’s Golf -- A.L. Walker Jr.

1925
Men’s Swimming & Diving -- Walter Krissell, one-meter diving

1927
Men’s Swimming & Diving -- William Wright, 50-yard freestyle

1930
Men’s Swimming & Diving -- Ray Ruddy, 440-yard freestyle

1937
Men’s Outdoor Track & Field -- Ben Johnson, 200-yard dash

1939
Men’s Outdoor Track & Field -- Richard Ganslen, pole vault

1944
Men’s Swimming & Diving -- Eugene Rogers, 220-yard freestyle
Men’s Swimming & Diving -- Charles Batterman, one-meter diving
Men’s Swimming & Diving -- Charles Batterman, three-meter diving

1945
Men’s Swimming & Diving -- Eugene Rogers, 220-yard freestyle

1950
Men’s Fencing -- Robert Nielson, foil

1951
Men’s Fencing (Servando Velarde)
Men’s Fencing -- Robert Nielson, foil
Men’s Fencing -- Daniel Chafetz, epee

1952
Men’s Fencing (Servando Velarde)
Men’s Outdoor Track & Field -- George Shaw, triple jump

1954
Men’s Fencing (Irving DeKoff)
Men’s Fencing -- Steve Sobel, sabre

1955
Men’s Fencing (Irving DeKoff)
Men’s Fencing -- Barry Pariser, sabre

1956
Men’s Fencing -- Ralph DeMarco, foil
Men’s Fencing -- Gerald Kaufman, sabre

1957
Men’s Fencing -- James Margolis, epee

1962
Men’s Fencing -- Barton Nisonson, sabre

1963
Men’s Fencing (Irving DeKoff)
Men’s Fencing -- Jay Lustig, foil

1965
Men’s Fencing (Irving DeKoff)
Men’s Fencing -- Joe Nalven, foil

1968
Men’s Fencing (Louis Bancuti)

1969
Men’s Fencing -- Anthony Kestler, foil

1970
Men’s Fencing -- Bruce Soriano, sabre

1971
Men’s Fencing (Louis Bancuti)
Men’s Fencing -- Bruce Soriano, sabre

1972
Men’s Fencing -- Bruce Soriano, sabre

1976
Men’s Fencing -- Brian Smith, sabre

1983
Men’s Swimming & Diving -- Tony Corbisiero, 1,650-yard freestyle

1985
Women’s Fencing -- Caitlin Bilodeaux, foil

1987
Men’s Fencing (George Kolombatovich/Aladar Kogler)
Men’s Fencing -- William Mindel, foil
Women’s Fencing -- Caitlin Bilodeaux, foil

1988
Men’s Fencing (George Kolombatovich/Aladar Kogler)
Men’s Fencing -- Marc Kent, foil
Men’s Fencing -- Robert Cottingham, sabre
Men’s Fencing -- Jay Normile, epee

1989
Men’s Fencing (George Kolombatovich/Aladar Kogler)
Men’s Fencing -- Jay Normile, epee

1990
Men’s Fencing -- David Mandell, sabre
Women’s Fencing -- Tzu Moy, foil

1991
Men’s Fencing -- Ben Atkins, foil
Men’s Fencing -- Marc Oshima, epee

1992
Men’s Fencing (George Kolombatovich/Aladar Kogler)

1993
Men’s Fencing (George Kolombatovich/Aladar Kogler)
Men’s Fencing -- Ben Atkins, epee

1998
Women’s Swimming & Diving -- Cristina Teuscher, 500-yard freestyle
Women’s Swimming & Diving -- Cristina Teuscher, 400-yard individual medley

2000
Women’s Swimming & Diving -- Cristina Teuscher, 400-meter freestyle
Women’s Swimming & Diving -- Cristina Teuscher, 400-meter individual medley

2001
Men’s Fencing -- Jed Dupree, foil

2005
Women's Fencing -- Emily Jacobson, saber

2007
Women’s Fencing -- Daria Schneider, saber