1903
Men’s Tennis -- E.B. Dewhurst, singles

1905
Men’s Tennis -- E.B. Dewhurst, singles
Men’s Tennis -- E.B. Dewhurst, doubles
Men’s Tennis -- H.B. Register, doubles

1908
Men’s Tennis -- H.M. Tilden, doubles
Men’s Tennis -- A. Thayer, doubles

1909
Men’s Tennis -- Wallace Johnson, singles
Men’s Tennis -- Wallace Johnson, doubles
Men’s Tennis -- A. Thayer, doubles

1921
Men’s Outdoor Track & Field -- Earl Eby, 800-yard run

1932
Men’s Outdoor Track & Field -- Grant McDougall, hammer throw

1941
Wrestling -- Dick DiBatista, 175 pounds

1942
Wrestling -- Dick DiBatista, 175 pounds

1953
Men’s Fencing (Lajos Csiszar)
Men’s Fencing -- Robert Parmocek, sabre
Men’s Fencing -- Jack Tori, epee

1954
Men’s Fencing -- Robert Goldman, foil

1959
Men’s Outdoor Track & Field -- Carl Shine, shot put

1967
Men’s Fencing -- Todd Makler, sabre

1968
Men’s Fencing -- Todd Makler, sabre

1969
Men’s Fencing (Lajos Csiszar)
Men’s Fencing -- Norman Braslow, sabre

1970
Men’s Fencing -- James Wetzler, epee

1972
Men’s Fencing -- Ernesto Fernandez, epee
Men’s Outdoor Track & Field -- Bruce Collins, 400-meter hurdles

1973
Men’s Fencing -- Brooke Makler, foil

1974
Men’s Outdoor Track & Field -- Bruce Collins, 440-yard hurdles

1976
Men’s Fencing -- Randy Eggleton, epee

1980
Men’s Fencing -- Paul Friedberg, sabre

1981
Men’s Fencing (David Micahnik)
Men’s Fencing -- Paul Friedberg, sabre

1984
Women’s Fencing -- Mary Jane O'Neill, foil

1986
Women’s Fencing (David Micahnik)
Men’s Fencing -- Chris O'Loughlin, epee

1997
Men’s Fencing -- Cliff Bayer, foil

2000
Wrestling -- Brett Matter, 157 pounds

2003
Men's Track & Field -- Brian Chaput, javelin throw
Men's Track & Field -- Sam Burley, 800-meter run

2006
Wrestling -- Matt Valenti, 133 pounds

2007
Wrestling -- Matt Valenti, 133 pounds