All-Time All-Ivy: Wrestling

Ivy League Outstanding Performers

Wrestler of the Year

Rookie of the Year

1984 John Orr, Princeton (142)
1985 John Orr, Princeton (142)
1986 Dave Cristiani, Princeton (118)
1987 Bob Hill, Brown (150)
1988 Bob Hill, Brown (150)
1989 Steve Hasenfus, Columbia (190)
1990 Pat Waters, Cornell (150)
1991 Jason Roach, Cornell (158)
1992 Mark Fergeson, Cornell (134)
1993 Mark Fergeson, Cornell (142)
1994 David Hirsch, Cornell (126)
1995 Nick Szerlip, Columbia (177)
1996 Willie Carpenter, Brown (126)

1997 Brandon Slay, Penn (167)
1998 Brandon Slay, Penn (167)
1999 Dustin DeNunzio, Harvard (141)
2000 Brett Matter, Penn (157)
2001 Mike Fickell, Penn (197)

2002 Yoshi Nakamura, Penn (157)
2003 Travis Lee, Cornell (125)
2004 Jesse Jantzen, Harvard (149)
2005 Travis Lee, Cornell (133)
2006 Troy Nickerson, Cornell (125)
2007 Matt Valenti, Penn (133

2008 J.P. O’Connor, Harvard (149)
2009 Mack Lewnes, Cornell (165)

1984 Chris Kane, Columbia (150)
1985 Peter Holmes, Harvard (158)
1986 E.C. Muelhaupt, Brown (158)
1987 Pat Waters, Cornell (142)
1988 Eric Kaufman, Cornell (118)
1989 Sam Cole, Harvard (126)
1990 Mark Fergeson, Cornell (134)
1991 Michael Warnick, Harvard (142)
1992 Mike Klinglesmith, Cornell (150)
1993 Willie Carpenter, Brown (126)
1994 Brandon Slay, Penn (167)
1995 Dustin DeNunzio, Harvard (126)
1996 Brett Matter, Penn (142) &
Ed Mosley, Harvard (158)
1997 Joe Killar, Harvard (150)
1998 Rick Springman, Penn (158)
1999 Bronson Lingamfelter, Brown (HWT)
2000 Max Odom, Harvard (149)
2001 Mason Lenhard, Penn (125) &
Jesse Jantzen, Harvard (149)
2002 Travis Lee, Cornell (125)
2003 Dustin Manotti, Cornell (149)
2004 Bode Ogunwole, Harvard (HWT)
2005 Jordan Leen, Cornell (141)
2006 Troy Nickerson, Cornell (125)
2007 Adam Frey, Cornell (133) &
J.P. O’Connor, Harvard
2008 Mike Grey, Cornell (133)
2009 Cam Simaz, Cornell (197)

All-Time First-Team All-Ivy League

1969-70 118- Roger Campbell, Columbia; 126- Steve Garner, Princeton; 134- Al Uyeda, Princeton; 142- Nate Resnick, Penn; 150- Ben Bishop, Cornell; 158- Tom Potts, Princeton; 167- Mark Faller, Harvard; 177- Kevin Milliken, Yale; 190- Emil Deliere, Princeton; HWT- Chuck Dressel, Princeton.

1970-71 118- Lee Klepper, Princeton; 126- Steve Garne, Princeton; 134- Al Uyeda, Princeton; 142- Dave Chan, Yale; 150- Pat Coleman, Harvard; 158- Alan Gaby, Yale; 167- Mark Faller, Harvard; 177- Rich Starr, Harvard; 190- Emil Deliere, Princeton; HWT- Chuck Dressel, Princeton.

1971-72 118- Lee Klepper, Princeton; 126- Dave Groverman, Penn; 134- Josh Henson, Harvard; 142- Kit Kuntze, Princeton; 150- Jeff Spendelow, Yale; 158- Alan Gaby, Yale; 167- Dave Crawford, Cornell; 177- Richie Starr, Harvard; 190- Emil Deliere, Princeton; HWT- Tim Karpoff, Yale.

1972-73 118- Dan Blakinger Harvard; 126- Dave Groverman, Penn; 134- Eric Lubell, Princeton; 142- Denis Underkoffler, Princeton; 150- Ray Sarinelli, Penn; 158- Dale Porter, Cornell; 167- Bob Sacavage, Columbia; 177- Dave Crawford, Cornell; 190- Richie Starr, Harvard; HWT- Tim Karpoff, Yale.

1973-74 118- Sal Lanuto, Columbia; 126- Dave Schaefer, Cornell; 134- Mike Nuckols, Princeton; 142- Denis Underkoffler, Princeton; 150- Ray Sarinelli, Penn; 158- Dale Porter, Cornell; 167- Jamie Fee, Columbia; 177- Dave Crawford, Cornell; 190- Walter Grote, Cornell; HWT- Tim Karpoff, Yale.

1974-75 118- Eric Waters, Penn; 126- Jerry Reid, Columbia; 134- Jeff Thorne, Penn; 142- Jim Bennett, Yale; 150- Ray Sarinelli, Penn; 158- Dale Porter, Cornell; 167- Jamie Fee, Columbia; 177- Kevin Young, Dartmouth; 190- Neal Brendel, Yale; HWT- Reggie Williams, Dartmouth.

1975-76 118 - Andy Sama, Columbia; 126- Dave Schaefer, Cornell; 134- Kevin McHugh, Columbia; 142- Denis Underkoffler, Princeton; 150- Jim Bennet, Yale; 158- Marty Schwartz, Yale; 167- Bill Miron, Princeton; 177- Keith Ely, Princeton; 190- Neal Brendel, Yale; HWT- John Sefter, Princeton.

1976-77 118- Ron Keene, Cornell; 126- Milt Yasunaga, Harvard; 134- Kevin Roesch, Princeton; 142- Steve Traylor, Yale; 150- Steve Grubman, Princeton; 158- Matt D'Annunzio, Yale; 167- Bill Miron, Princeton; 177- Keith Ely, Princeton; 190- Joe Cooper, Yale; HWT- John Sefter, Princeton.

1977-78 118- Bill Hawley, Princeton; 126 - Jerry Reid, Columbia; 134 - Kevin McHugh, Columbia; 142 - Steve Grubman, Princeton; 150 - Steve Traylor, Yale; 158 - Matt D'Annunzio, Yale; 167 - Bill Miron, Princeton; 117 - Keith Ely, Princeton; 190 - Sal D'Agostino, Harvard; HVY- John Sefter, Princeton.

1978-79 118 - Steve McKenna, Columbia; 126 - Leigh Tonai, Yale; 134 - Bill Patterson, Cornell; 142 - Gene Nighman, Cornell; 150 - Steve Traylor, Yale; 158 - Allen Washington, Yale; 167 - Jack Moses, Yale; 177 - Chris Rugg, Cornell; 190 - Keith Ely, Princeton; HVY - Jay Craddock, Columbia.

1979-80 118 - Pat Alberti, Columbia; 126 - Mark Murray, Cornell; 134 - Kirk Dabney, Princeton; 142 - Gene Nighman, Cornell; 150 - Tim Harrison, Cornell; 158 - Allen Washington, Yale; 167 - Rick Wetzler, Yale; 177 - Jim Fraivillig, Princeton; 190 - Matt Boyle, Yale; HVY - Jay Craddock, Columbia.

1980-81 118 - Joe Rabin, Columbia; 126 - Sam Edwards, Cornell; 134 - John Orr, Princeton; 142 - Bob Jeackel, Columbia; 150 - Gene Nighman, Cornell; 158 - Greg Thomas, Columbia; 167 - Mark Schlitt, Penn; 177 - Jim Fraivillig, Princeton; 190 - Paul Pitcher, Penn; HVY- Jay Craddock, Columbia.

1981-82 118- Paul Widerman, Harvard; 126 - Dave Hamer, Columbia; 134 - Rusty Fiste, Princeton; 142 - John Orr, Princeton; 150 - Dave Galdi, Columbia; 158 - Mike Mankowich, Cornell; 167 - Colin Grissom, Yale; 177 - Rick Wetzler, Yale; 190 - Terry Kent, Cornell; HVY - Jim Phills, Harvard.

1982-83 118- Dave Crisanti, Princeton; 126 - Rusty Fiste, Princeton; 134 - Nick King, Yale; 142 - Andy McNerney, Harvard; 150 - Pat Welch, Cornell; 158 - Mike Mankowich, Cornell; 167 - Colin Grissom. Yale; 177 - Sean Wallace, Harvard; 190 - Matt Boyle, Yale; HVY - Jim Phills, Harvard.

1983-84 118- Dave Crisanti, Princeton; 126 - Robert Arao, Cornell; 134 - Nick King, Yale; 142 - John Orr, Princeton; 150 - Pat Welch, Cornell; 158 - Mike Mankowich, Cornell; 167 - Bill Lubell, Columbia; 177 - Ken Griffin, Cornell; 190 - Sean Wallace, Harvard; HWT- Matt Boyle, Yale.

1984-85 118 - Dave Crisanti, Princeton; 126 - Dave Barry, Columbia; 134 - Nick King, Yale; 142 - John Orr, Princeton; 150 - Bill Ehling, Princeton; 158 - Pat Welch, Cornell; 167 - Scott O'Neil, Cornell; 177 - Barry Bausano, Harvard; 190 - Sean Wallace, Harvard; HWT - Rich Pilkington, Columbia.

1985-86 118 - Dave Crisanti, Princeton; 126 - John Vogt, Columbia; 134 - Brian Crane, Princeton; 142 - Bob Hill, Brown; 150 - Mike Novogratz, Princeton; 158 - Chris Kane, Columbia; 167 - Andy Taitel, Penn; 177 - Scott O'Neil, Cornell; 190 - Steve Salzman, Yale; HWT - Rich Pilkington, Columbia.

1986-87 118 - Ken Gaudreau, Columbia; 126 - Charles Lee, Yale; 134 - Jack Macko, Cornell; 142 - Pat Waters, Cornell; 150 - Bob Hill, Brown; 158 - Mike Novogratz, Princeton; 167 - Andy Rice, Cornell; 177 - Steve Farrell, Harvard; 190 - Steve Hasenfus, Columbia; HWT - Dan McInnis, Yale.

1987-88 118 - Chuck Boyle, Columbia; 126 - Jerry Graziano, Cornell; 134 - Jack Macko, Cornell; 142 - Pat Waters, Cornell; 150 - Joe Guciardo, Cornell; 158 - Bob Hill, Brown; 167 - Pete Holmes, Harvard and Andy Rice, Cornell; 177 - Paul Roux, Columbia; 190 - Steve Hasenfus, Columbia; HWT - Jeff Farrow, Cornell.

1988-89 118 - Ken Gaudreau, Columbia; 126 - Todd Johnson, Columbia; 134 - Dan Bertges, Cornell; 142 - Kirk Nolan, Princeton; 150 - Toby Johnson, Columbia; 158 - E.C. Muelhaupt, Brown; 167 - Joe Mocco, Brown; 177 - Lance Minor, Brown; 190 - Steve Hasenfus, Columbia; HWT- Jeff Farrow, Cornell.

1989-90 118 - Adam Condo, Columbia; 126 - Jerry Graziano, Cornell; 134 - Mark Fergeson, Cornell; 142 - Jim Pedro, Brown; 150 - Pat Waters, Cornell; 158 - Lee Coulter, Brown; 167 - Joe Gannon, Princeton; 177 - Larry Guarino, Princeton; 190 - Ted Casto, Brown and Tim Szecz, Cornell; HWT- Mark Semlow, Yale.

1990-91 118 - Adam Condo, Columbia and Marc McFarland, Cornell; 126 - Chuck Boyle, Columbia; 134 - Mark Fergeson, Cornell; 142 - Michael Warnick Brown; 150 - Jason Roach, Cornell; 158 - Joe Mocco, Brown; 167 - John Gluckow, Princeton; 177 - Ben Morgan, Cornell; 190 - Ted Casto, Brown and Tim Szecz, Cornell; HWT- Adam Green, Penn

1991-92 118 - Jim Meckley, Cornell; 126 - David Hirsch, Cornell; 134 - Mark Fergeson, Cornell; 142 - Steve Thoma, Brown; 150 - Sepp Dobler, Brown; 158 - Jason Roach, Cornell; 158 - 167 - Joe Mocco, Brown and Mike New, Cornell; 177 - Kyle Rackley; Cornell and Chris Tokarski, Brown; 190 - Dave Walton, Princeton; HWT - Bruce Morgan, Cornell

1992-93 118 - Mike Mulrooney, Brown; 126 - David Hirsch, Cornell; 134 - Paul Collier, Brown, 142 - Mark Fergeson, Cornell and Jim Pedro, Brown; 150 - Frank Fronhofer, Harvard; 158 - Joe Mocco, Brown; 167 - Chip Foster, Cornell; 177 - Kyle Rackley, Cornell; 190 - Ted Casto, Brown; HWT - Bruce Morgan, Cornell

1993-94 118 - Gary Baker, Penn; 126 - David Hirsch, Cornell; Dave Gustovich, Brown; 134 - Mike Yancosky, Cornell; 142 -Glenn Walter, Cornell; 150 - Joel Torretti, Cornell; 167 - Brandon Slay, Penn; 177 - John Drosos, Harvard; 190 - Brian Butler, Penn; HWT - Joey Allen, Penn

1994-95 118 - Dennis Kitko, Cornell; 126 - Carl Keske, Cornell; 134 - Mike Yancosky, Cornell; 142 - Paul Collier, Brown; 150 - Simon Weaver, Brown; 158 - Tivon Abel, Brown; Doug Roskos, Princeton; 167 - Joel Selcher, Princeton; Brandon Slay, Penn; 177 - Carlos Eason, Cornell; 190 - Nick Szerlip, Columbia; HWT - Joey Allen, Penn

1995-96 118 - Ben Hatta, Penn; Peter Poretta, Brown; 126 - Willie Carpenter, Brown; Dustin DeNunzio, Harvard; 134 - Carl Keske, Cornell; 142 - Brett Matter, Penn; 150 - Steve Gerstung, Harvard; 158 - Ed Mosley, Harvard; Jeff New, Cornell; 167 - Josh Bailer, Penn; 177 - Clinton Matter, Penn; 190 - Carlos Eason, Cornell; HWT - Joey Allen, Penn

1996-97 118 - Ben Hatta, Penn; 126 - Willie Carpenter, Brown; 134 - Carl Keske, Cornell; 142 - Brett Matter, Penn; 150 - Joe Killar, Harvard; 158 - Tivon Abel, Brown; 167- Brandon Slay, Penn; 177 - Clinton Matter, Penn; 190 - Carlos Eason, Cornell; HWT - Joey Allen, Penn

1997-98 118 - Aaron Taylor, Cornell; 126 - Steve Walker, Penn; 134 - Dustin DeNunzio, Harvard; 142 - Arkee Allen, Columbia; 150 - Leo Urbinelli, Cornell; 158 - Tivon Abel, Brown; 167 - Brandon Slay, Penn; 177 - Nate Burroughs, Brown; 190 - Andrei Rodzianko, Penn; HWT - Bandele Adeniyi-Bada, Penn

1998-99 125 - Pete Poretta, Brown; 133 - Livi DiRubbo, Brown; Juan Venturi, Princeton; 141 - Dustin DeNunzio, Harvard; 149 - Shawn Bradley, Cornell; 157 - Kevin Kurtz, Harvard; 165 - Ryan Bonfiglio, Princeton; Rick Springman, Penn; 174 - Joe Tucceri, Cornell; 184 - Nate Burroughs, Brown; 197 - Andrei Rodzianko, Penn; HWT - Bandele Adeniyi-Bada, Penn

1999-00 125 - Aaron Taylor, Cornell; 133 - Livio DiRubbo, Brown; 141 - Ben New, Cornell; 149 - Jon Gough, Penn; Max Odom, Harvard; 157 - Brett Matter, Penn; 165 - Joey Killar, Harvard; 174 - Rick Springman, Penn; 184 - Rost Aizenberg, Cornell; Karl Rittger, Brown; 197 - Bob Greenleaf, Cornell; HWT - Bandele Adeniyi-Bada, Penn

2000-01 125 - Mason Lenhard, Penn; 133 - Matt Picarsic, Harvard; 141 - Joe Clarke, Princeton; 149 - Jesse Jantzen, Harvard; 157 - Yoshi Nakamura, Penn; 165 - Pat O'Donnell, Harvard; Tim Ortman, Penn; 174 - Jim Stanec, Cornell; 184 - Fran Volpe, Harvard; Marcus Schontube, Penn; 197 - Mike Fickell, Penn; Corey Anderson, Cornell; HWT - Bronson Lingamfelter, Brown; Dawid Rechul, Harvard; Michael Faust, Penn

2001-02 125 - Mason Lenhard, Penn; 133 - Kevin El-Hayek, Harvard; 141 - Clint Frease, Brown; 149 - Jesse Jantzen, Harvard; 157 - Yoshi Nakamura, Penn; 165 - Josh Henson, Penn; 174 - Greg Parker, Princeton; 184 - Clint Wattenberg, Cornell; 197 - Nick Ciarcia, Brown; HWT - Bronson Lingamfelter, Brown

2002-03 125 - Travis Lee, Cornell; 133 - Alejandro Alvarez, Cornell; 141 - Clint Frease, Brown; 149 - Jesse Jantzen, Harvard; 157 - Gabe Webster, Cornell; 165 - Matt Palmer, Columbia; 174 - Tyler Baier, Cornell; 184 - Greg Parker, Princeton; 197 - Matt Greenberg, Cornell; Hwt. - Matt Feast, Penn

2003-04 125 - Matt Valenti, Penn; 133 - Travis Lee, Cornell; 141 - Doug McGraw, Penn; 149 - Jesse Jantzen, Harvard; 157 - Scott Roth, Cornell; 165 - Sean Jenkins, Brown; 174 - Tyler Baier, Cornell; 184 - Jerry Rinaldi, Cornell; 197 - Matt Greenberg, Cornell; HWT - Matt Feast, Penn

2004-05 125 - Robbie Peterson, Harvard; 133 - Travis Lee, Cornell; 141 - Jordan Leen, Cornell; 149 - Dustin Manotti, Cornell ; 157 - Devin Mesanko, Columbia; 165 - Matt Palmer, Columbia; 174 - Joe Mazzurco, Cornell; 184 - Tyler Baier, Cornell; 197 - Jerry Rinaldi, Cornell; HWT - Matt Feast, Penn

2005-06 125 - Troy Nickerson, Cornell; 133 - Matt Valenti, Penn; 141 - Matt Meltzer, Harvard; 149 - Matt Dragon, Penn; 157 - Andrew Flanagan, Harvard; 165 - Shawn Kitchner, Brown; 174 - Matt Herrington, Penn; 184 - Joe Mazzurco, Cornell; 197 - Jerry Rinaldi, Cornell; HWT - Bode Ogunwole, Harvard

2006-07 125 - Troy Nickerson, Cornell; 133 - Matt Valenti, Penn; 141 - Max Meltzer, Harvard; 149 - Jordan Leen, Cornell; 157 - Matt Dragon, Penn; 165 - Zach Shanaman, Penn; 174 - Matt Palmer, Columbia; 184 - Louis Caputo, Harvard; 197 - Jerry Rinaldi, Cornell; HWT - Zach Hammond, Cornell

2007-08 125 - Mike Rodriguez, Cornell; 133 - Mike Grey, Cornell; 141 - Rick Rappo, Penn; 149 - J.P. O’Connor, Harvard; 157 - Jordan Leen, Cornell; 165 - Zack Shanaman, Penn; 174 - Steve Anceravage, Cornell; 184 - Lior Zamir, Penn; 197 - Justin Kerber, Cornell; HWT - Levon Mock, Brown

2008-09 125 - Troy Nickerson, Cornell; 133 - Mike Grey, Cornell; 141 - Rick Rappo, Penn; 149 - Cesar Grajales, Penn; 157 - J.P. O'Connor, Harvard; 165 - Mack Lewnes, Cornell; 174 - Steve Anceravage, Cornell; 184 - Louis Caputo, Harvard; 197 - Cam Simaz, Cornell; HWT - Ryan Flores, Columbia

THREE-TIME & FOUR-TIME FIRST-TEAM ALL-IVY SELECTIONS

Since All-Ivy selections began in 1969-70, several wrestlers have gained first-team All-Ivy honors three times and eight have been selected four times. The four-time selectees are: Keith Ely, Princeton, 1976-77-78-79; John Orr, Princeton, 1981-82-84-85; Dave Crisanti, Princeton, 1983-84-85-86; Mark Fergeson, Cornell, 1990-91-92-93; Joe Mocco, Brown 1989-91-92-93; Joey Allen, Penn, 1994-95-96-97; Brandon Slay, Penn, 1994-95-97-98; Jesse Jantzen, Harvard, 2001-02-03-04; Jerry Rinaldi, Cornell, 2004-05-06-07.

Three-time selectees are: Emil Deliere, Princeton, 1970-71-72; Rich Starr, Harvard, 1971-72-73; Tim Karpoff, Yale, 1972-73-74; Dave Crawford, Cornell, 1972-73-74; John Sefter, Princeton, 1976-77-78; Steve Traylor, Yale, 1977-78-79; Gene Nighman, Cornell, 1979-80-81; Jay Craddock, Columbia, 1979-80-81; Matt Boyle, Yale, 1980-83-84; Mike Mankowich, Cornell, 1982-83-84; Nick King, Yale, 1983-84-85; Pat Welch, Cornell, 1983-84-85; Sean Wallace, Harvard, 1983-84-85; Bob Hill, Brown, 1986-87-88; Steve Hasenfus, Columbia, 1987-88-89; Pat Waters, Cornell, 1987-88-90; Ted Casto, Brown, 1991-92-93; David Hirsch, Cornell, 1992-93-94; Carlos Eason, Cornell, 1995-96-97; Carl Keske, Cornell, 1995-96-97; Tivon Abel, Brown, 1996-97-98; Dustin DeNunzio, Harvard, 1996-98-99; Brett Matter, Penn, 1996-97, 00; Bandele Adeniyi-Bada, Penn, 1998-99-00; Tyler Baier, Cornell, 2003-04-05; Matt Feast, Penn, 2003-04-05; Travis Lee, Cornell, 2003-04-05; Troy Nickerson, Cornell, 2006-07-09.